Little Lake Theatre: A New Home for Pittsburgh Theater Lovers

As it nears its 80th anniversary, Little Lake Theatre is growing rapidly — in patrons and performers — thanks to an open-door attitude and quality productions.

Little Lake Theatre Finds a Home in Canonsburg

On the outskirts of Canonsburg, Little Lake Theatre hides in an unassuming red barn. The name is accurate; nestled among trees that seem to be constantly rustling with a pleasant breeze, the 78-year-old theater sits within a stone’s throw of Canonsburg Lake.

If you’re the sort of arts lover who cares more for passion than pretension, you might discover a new favorite troupe in Little Lake. It’s the sort of place that wins you over with charm and wit and becomes a frequent destination.

And if you’re a performer, you just might find your home.

Little Lake Theatre’s History

Little Lake is in the midst of a growth spurt. This season, their number of patrons is expected to be double what it was in 2022. Revenue from subscriptions is up more than 140% in just the past two seasons. Their summer camps, an important source of income — and a pathway to the arts for area children — have also grown. They’re producing more shows and performing more often.

This arrives as many corners of the theater world are struggling to retain money and audiences. Patrick Cannon, Little Lake’s artistic director, says that while the economics of a community-based theater are much different than those of a major regional house, the key to the theater’s growth has been welcoming as many collaborators as possible.

“The idea [is], the more the merrier,” Cannon says. “Bringing more hands on deck, more people in the room, more people on the production teams. Expanding — and opening — the door, and holding it as firmly open as we can.”

Actor in a conductor uniform holding a smoking miniature model train on a tray under stage lights.

A Welcoming Community for Performers

While many of the people involved with Little Lake (including performers) are volunteers, that expansion has also involved adding staff positions, another rarity for theater groups in 2026. Katie Flanigan, who joined Little Lake over the summer as director of production, came to the job with a lifetime of relevant experience.

“I originally connected with Little Lake in 2005 — when I went to camp here,” Flanigan says. “As a kid, I got those roots connected here at the Lake … I feel like this is genuinely the first place where I felt what community was.”

- Advertisement -

“I became an apprentice, was involved all throughout high school, became a stage manager here … You can always walk in and you’re like, ‘I’m back,’ like time hasn’t passed at all — but, at the same time, there’s this evolution of what we look like now.”

You can see evidence of that evolution in the theater’s upcoming offerings. There are (and, Cannon insists, always will be) the broadly popular musicals and comedies that are the hallmark of the theater; this season featured a sold-out run of The Wizard of Oz, complete with a full children’s choir and orchestra, and will end with White Christmas.

In between, though, there are shows that one might not expect from a suburban theater. The off-Broadway hit Dracula: A Comedy of Terrors also made its regional debut at Little Lake.

“It’s a show that I’ve heard of in regional spaces that people have loved,” Flanigan says. “It’s nice to bring something fresh to this space.”

Nathan Walter, Little Lake’s associate artistic director, helmed Big Fish this past September; the musical is adapted from the Tim Burton film (and the Daniel Wallace novel). “It’s the closest thing to Our Town with music,” Walter says. “I’m looking forward to sharing the love of this show with our audiences.”

Cannon is looking forward to staging the teen drama The Wolves, about tensions among a girls’ soccer team. Unlike many productions — which cast young-looking adults — Little Lake’s production will use teen actors to play teen characters. Young performers, Cannon says, “love an opportunity to sink their teeth into something really juicy.”

Something for Everyone

“At the core of the company is accessibility,” Walter adds. “Our artists — from our production staff to our actors — feel seen and feel heard. They feel that they can come here and participate in a safe and sustainable process … we try to take the pressure out.”

The season finale, White Christmas, will also represent a daring new effort from Little Lake, as they seek to grow beyond their location itself. The show will be the first produced at the nearby Canonsburg Educational and Cultural Institute, a much larger, proscenium theater. How does a space known for its inviting and idyllic location preserve the spirit on the road?

“A church is not its building — it is its congregation,” Cannon says. “I think that we would be Little Lake whenever we went.”

Stage actors performing a dramatic scene set on a pickleball court during a theatrical production.

Looking to the Future of Little Lake Theatre

That sentiment may not refer simply to a trip down the street — a bigger change is in the works.

“We have intentions to build our own new building here on our property, too,” Cannon reveals. “We’re dreaming beyond [this building,] as good as this building has been to us.”

Shocking though that may be to audiences used to the same space (and performers used to treading the same boards), the magic is in the people — and, perhaps, the air.

“When you leave a show here, it smells like summertime,” Cannon says. “You’re in the woods, you can hear the birds chirping … It’s just a whole different energy. I think that we try to wipe the pretension out of theater.”

About the Author

Sean Collier is the editor-in-chief of Shady Ave and the arts and culture editor of TABLE Magazine. Before joining the TABLE Media team, he spent nearly 15 years as a writer, editor and columnist at Pittsburgh Magazine. As the in-house film critic for the top-rated WDVE Morning Show since 2009, he’s been Pittsburgh’s most widely heard voice on movies for nearly two decades. A Pittsburgh native, Sean has since 2020 appeared weekly on KDKA-TV’s popular Pittsburgh Today Live talk show. He’s the co-founder of Vigilance Theater Group and an active stand-up comedian and event host. He can be found on Instagram and Twitter at @seancollierpgh.

Photos by Hawk Photography

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR EMAIL NEWSLETTER

We respect your privacy.

Related Articles

A Fresh Pour of Pittsburgh Nostalgia at Steel Town Tavern

Family recipes, a bit of Steel City swagger and a whole lot of heart are on the menu at Steel Town Tavern, a new pub taking over the former Murray Avenue Grill space.

Meet More Than 100 Ceramic Rabbits at Contemporary Craft’s ‘No Longer Prey’ Exhibit

In the new exhibition No Longer Prey, artist Kara Zuzu creates a colony of ceramic rabbits — and demonstrates that there’s always strength in numbers.

Exploring Pittsburgh’s South Hills: A Guide to Southern Living

Discover Pittsburgh’s South Hills, from walkable Mt. Lebanon streets and local dining to parks and more.